Pricing is the most honest copy on your site. Whatever the brand voice promises, your tiers and discounts reveal the truth about confidence, value, and how you want to be treated. A company that launches with three tidy plans-clearly named, cleanly bounded-tells me they want me to succeed without a phone call. A company that opens with "contact us" and a PDF tells me I'm entering a negotiation where my time is a variable. Both can be fine; both are stories that teach customers how to behave.
Discounts are where the story gets loud. If a prospect learns they can reliably receive 20"“30% off at quarter"‘end, they will not only wait for it; they will design their procurement process around it. The sales theater becomes part of the product. Now your champion helps you instead of the other way around"”because the "win" is the discount, not the outcomes you promised.
There is a better way than either rigid list pricing or chaos. The most durable pricing strategies I've seen share three traits: a narrative about value that makes sense to a human, a small number of levers that map to actual costs, and a discount policy that is a policy, not an improv night.
Specifics that work in practice:
-
Anchor to value, not just inputs. If your service replaces headcount, price against the job to be done with explicit ROI math. If your product scales with usage, price along the curve where the customer wins more as you win more; don't lock value behind unrelated limits.
-
Pick two levers. Teams love five"‘dimensional pricing because it feels "fair." Customers hate it because it feels like a trap. Storage plus seats, messages plus latency budget"”two levers are enough to map to your costs and to the buyer's mental model.
-
Publish a baseline, negotiate exceptions with receipts. Enterprise buyers will need terms for governance and risk. That doesn't mean your ACV should be a dice roll. Decide which exceptions are allowed (e.g., data residency, custom SLAs) and which are not (e.g., "lifetime" discounts that forever anchor the relationship to a moment in a quarter).
-
Make discounts expire for reasons that a buyer respects. Volume commitments, longer terms, multi"‘product adoption"”these are reasons. "My VP asked" is not. When the reason maps to the customer's win, they will explain your discount to their finance team for you.
Two stories:
We sold a mid"‘market analytics product where implementation time varied wildly based on data hygiene. A naive per"‘seat price punished clean customers and subsidized messy ones. Switching to a base platform fee plus a one"‘time "data boarding" price made everyone's life better. Clean customers moved in fast without feeling overcharged; messy customers saw the real work and budgeted accordingly. Our sales cycles shortened because the story made sense.
Another team offered an unstructured "pilot discount" that could be extended "if needed." It was always needed. Pilots dragged on as buyers ran production through the "pilot" to avoid the real price. We changed the policy to a time"‘boxed pilot with explicit success criteria, followed by a retro credit on the first year if the criteria were met. Conversions went up; the perception of fairness returned.
Kindness matters here. Good pricing respects the buyer's constraints. When a champion says, "I can't do multi"‘year," believe them and design paths that still reward partnership (e.g., a smaller annual uplift with a clawback if churn happens for reasons in your control). The goal is not to extract; it is to build a relationship that survives a reorg.
Case notes
The most enduring SaaS pricing stories (e.g., Slack's fair billing) work because they make moral sense to ordinary humans.
Beware of hidden free tiers: extremely generous free allowances can backfire by creating cultural resistance to paying later. Be explicit about thresholds and the value that paid unlocks.